Discover Banana Bay Resort & Marina, an adult-only beachfront retreat in Key West offering cabana rooms, free Wi-Fi, breakfast, and a marina near Duval Street and Hemingway Home. Enjoy a calm stay with pool, hot tub, pet-friendly rooms, and easy airport a
Recent guests highlight a laid-back atmosphere with unique waterfront moments and friendly service, while opinions vary on the resort’s overall upkeep and style.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Banana Bay Resort & Marina embodies a unique coastal retreat tucked along the shores of Key West, Florida. With a rating of 3.3, this adult-only beachfront property offers travelers a blend of laid-back charm and scenic oceanfront views. Located conveniently at 2319 N Roosevelt Blvd, just a few miles from Key West International Airport and the vibrant Duval Street, it serves as a peaceful gateway for visitors eager to explore cultural landmarks such as the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum.
The resort’s cabana rooms, perched right next to the outdoor pool, receive unanimous praise for their inviting ambiance and enhanced privacy. Guests like Joe Whittington highlight the cabana experience as uniquely refreshing, with moments such as swimming alongside wild dolphins by the boat ramp adding an unforgettable touch of natural wonder. These rooms, equipped with kitchens and air conditioning, strike a balance between comfort and convenience, appealing especially to those who appreciate self-catering options.
Banana Bay Resort & Marina also emphasizes genuine hospitality, with attentive staff contributing significantly to the overall guest experience. From bartenders who create memorable evenings to helpful guides recommending local activities, the team fosters a warm and welcoming atmosphere that resonates beyond the accommodation itself.
Guests looking for a blend of relaxation and accessibility will find much to enjoy here. Amenities like free Wi-Fi, complimentary breakfast served near the cabanas, and pet-friendly policies add layers of comfort while maintaining a smoke-free and peaceful environment. Although the resort does not offer a fitness center, its prime location encourages outdoor activities, including exploring key cultural sites or enjoying leisurely bike rides, as historic Fantasy Fest attendees have shared.
While some reviews suggest the property has seen better days, the new ownership appears committed to preserving the resort’s charm and keeping the premises well-maintained. This evolving narrative reflects the challenges and delights of staying in a genuine Key West waterfront locale where nature, history, and hospitality converge.
In sum, Banana Bay Resort & Marina offers more than just a place to stay—it offers an experience that blends the intimacy of coastal living with the pulse of a historic island town. For travelers seeking a serene yet vibrant backdrop on the edge of the Gulf, it remains a worthy destination that invites discovery and relaxation.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
This place is under new ownership. I stayed here during Fantasy Fest, and it was great. The cabana rooms next to the pool are awesome. Get a cabana room if you can. It's a totally different vibe and experience, from the rest of the hotel. The bartender was super. I swam in the water next to the boat ramp and dolphins came over to me and swam with me. Can't guarantee that it's going to happen to anyone else, but it was kind of magical. After a circus like day of running around Duval Street, retreating back to this place, and sitting in the rocking chairs at the beach and watching the sunset with a pina colada drink in your hand, it's the kind of thing songs and dreams are made of. Enjoy!
I am shocked at these reviews! We are bikers, and rode our Harleys in October, down from Michigan/Ohio for Fantasy Fest! This was in 2012, and in 10 years this place, with a private beach, wonderful breakfasts each morning out at the end of the cabana's, and well maintained, has gone downhill from a "resort" to barely a motel??? Our cabana for 3 was perfect! Nicely maintained, clean, and all our "neighbors" were great, and friendly!!! Perfectly located, close to downtown area, and dockside for big ships!!! I always admired the hotel part across from us! Just looked so beautiful! Yes, pics are deceiving! We would love to book for next year, and the Rockfest Celebration but, not with bad reviews. Can someone let me know, please.
We came into town on a whim and booked here. We had the pleasure of having a window over looking the Gulf and it was gorgeous! The showers and bed were nice along with pool. The hot tub wasn't too hot so we didn't get in but would have liked to. The staff here tho we're awesome and really made our whole trip!! One in particular, Jason, was phenomenal!!! Very helpful and real about what to do here and made our stay amazing! We even left a tablet in our room and they called to return it graciously! Thank you again!!!!:)
This adult-only beachfront resort and marina is 3 miles from Key West International Airport and 2 miles from Duval Street and the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum.
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Florida. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
18,185 reviews 907 Whitehead St, Key West, FL 33040, United States
15,974 reviews 601 Howard England Way, Key West, FL 33040, United States
43,074 reviews 1400 Whitehead St, Key West, FL 33040, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Discover Kona Kai Motel, a 4.5star Sanibel Island gem offering spacious rooms with kitchens, free WiFi, and an outdoor pool. Nes...
Experience a warm, clean, and comfortable stay at The Pines Motel in Crivitz, WI. Enjoy petfriendly rooms, free WiFi, and person...
Discover Green Valley Motel, a reliable 3star hotel in Marlboro, NY. Enjoy clean rooms, helpful staff, and convenient business am...
California InnYuba City offers clean, quiet rooms with free WiFi and parking. Familyfriendly and accessible, this inn provides ...
Budget Motel Rockwood offers petfriendly, airconditioned rooms with free WiFi and parking. Located at 608 S Gateway Ave, it's i...
Discover Longview Inn, offering spacious, budgetfriendly rooms with essential amenities like free WiFi, parking, and petfriendl...
Discover Motel 8 Plus. Las Vegas, offering clean, comfortable rooms with free WiFi and parking. Enjoy a welcoming, petfriendly e...
Experience comfort and convenience at Grand Mark lodging, a familyowned hotel in Grandville, MI. Enjoy clean rooms with microwave...
Experience a quiet, kidfriendly retreat at Rocky Neck Inn & Suites in Niantic, CT. Enjoy spacious rooms with kitchens, safe surro...
Discover SLS South Beach, a chic Miami Beach hotel near Ocean Drive. Enjoy modern design, lively pool parties, impeccable service,...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
